Computed from player tags · Not ranked by quality
24 games like Mafia II: Definitive Edition (2026)
Every game below overlaps with Mafia II: Definitive Edition on things players said about it rather than on our opinion of what feels alike. Each entry shows what it matched on, so you can throw out the ones matching on the part you did not care about.
The games like Mafia II: Definitive Edition on a map
Compare the whole catalogueThe same 24 games, plotted rather than listed. The two axes below are the ones the ranking is built from, so a game sitting high and right is a game the formula placed near the top. Change either axis to see the field a different way. Where we hold a publisher wordmark, the game is drawn as its mark rather than a dot.
24 games have both
Axes are fitted to these 24 games rather than the full 0 to 100 scale, because a filtered list shares a narrow band and would otherwise sit in one corner. End values are marked. A point on the left edge is the lowest of thesegames, not a low score.
Players. The share of Steam reviews marked positive, pulled toward the catalogue average in proportion to how few reviews stand behind it. A game with 200 reviews moves a long way toward the average; one with 200,000 barely moves at all. Without this a title sitting at 100 percent on nine reviews outranks Half-Life 2 at 98 percent on 278,000.
Popularity. A blend of two things that are not the same. Audience is how many people wrote a Steam review, which is a floor on how many played it. Reach is how many language editions of Wikipedia document the game, which is cultural footprint rather than sales. A game can score high on one and low on the other: a huge free-to-play title has audience without reach, and a landmark console exclusive has reach without a Steam audience at all. Where both exist they are averaged; where only one does, that one carries it.
- Mobile
- Multi-platform
- PC
- Xbox
Every point links to that game's entry. The value map and the reception map are fixed views of the same data.
How positions are decided
No paid placement, no favouritism, live third-party data
- Placed by the published method, not by us. Every coordinate is computed from the axis definitions and weights printed on this site. Nobody moves a point. See the axes.
- Nothing here is paid for. No sponsored placements, no promoted slots, no arrangement of any kind affects a position. If that ever changes it will be labelled and sit outside the ranking.
- No favouritism, including our own. The 16 games we have written full reviews of are scored by exactly the same formula as the other 1,510, from the same third-party inputs, and they land where it puts them. Our own opinion of a game does not enter its coordinates.
- A position is not an endorsement. It says how a game was received and what it costs, not that we recommend it. Where we do recommend something, it carries a written review with a name on it.
- Fetched from live third-party data. Player sentiment from Steam, critic aggregates as published on store pages, prices checked hourly, attention from Wikipedia. Each figure carries its source and the date it was read, and we do not adjust any of them.
The short version
- Closest match: Mafia II, which both open world, crime, story-rich and atmospheric.
- Mafia II: Definitive Edition is tagged Action, Adventure, Crime, Open World, Story Rich, Sexual Content, Nudity, Violent by Steam players. Those tags are what the matching runs on.
- 24 games qualify, each with at least fifty player reviews behind its sentiment figure.
- 2 are from the same studio: Mafia: Definitive Edition, Mafia III: Definitive Edition.
Why players value Mafia II: Definitive Edition
The five things Steam players tag Mafia II: Definitive Edition with most. This is the yardstick every game below is measured against: the closer a game matches these, the more it is likely to scratch the same itch.
- Action
- Adventure
- Crime
- Open World
- Story Rich
| Reception | on Steam (74% of 38,558) |
|---|---|
| Watch-outs | no widespread problems reported by players |
| Price | $29.99 |
Tags, sentiment and reported problems come from Steam players; the story line is from Wikipedia. We do not add a written opinion of our own.
How these were matched
Steam tags carry the most weight, because players apply them and they describe how a game feels rather than how it was filed. Souls-like, Atmospheric and Cozy exist as tags and as nothing else, which is exactly the vocabulary this question needs. Formal genres count for less, themes and a shared studio for more.
Tags carried by more than a third of the catalogue are thrown out before matching. Nearly everything is tagged Singleplayer, so matching on it is matching on nothing. That cutoff is computed from the catalogue rather than fixed, so it moves as the catalogue grows.
All 24, closest first
- 1
Mafia II
Why it matched: both open world, crime, story-rich and atmospheric; shares 15 player tags including Crime, Story Rich and Sexual Content; published by the same company.
War hero Vito Scaletta becomes entangled with the mob in hopes of paying his father’s debts. Vito works to prove himself, climbing the family ladder with crimes of larger reward and consequence.
Mafia II at a glance Released 2010 Studio Not recorded Player sentiment 74% positive of 38,540 Price $29.99 Verdict: GamingPickz Score 6.8/10 · Steam: (74% of 38,540)
Matches Mafia II: Definitive Edition on: 5 of 5 — Action, Adventure, Crime, Open World, Story Rich
Why players like it: Action, Adventure, Crime, Open World, Story Rich — the tags Steam players apply most
Price vs Mafia II: Definitive Edition: $29.99 — about the same price
Watch-outs: players report performance and stutter, crashes and freezes (details)
Shared with Mafia II: Definitive Edition:CrimeStory RichSexual ContentNudityViolentThird PersonThird-Person ShooterGore
- 2
Mafia: Definitive Edition
Why it matched: made by the same studio, Hangar 13; both open world, crime, story-rich and atmospheric; shares 13 player tags including Crime, Story Rich and Sexual Content; released around the same time (2020).
An inadvertent brush with the mob thrusts cabdriver Tommy Angelo into the world of organized crime. Initially uneasy about falling in with the Salieri family, the rewards become too big to ignore.
Mafia: Definitive Edition at a glance Released 2020 Studio Hangar 13 Player sentiment 87% positive of 110,615 Price $39.99 Verdict: GamingPickz Score 7.9/10 · Steam: (87% of 110,615)
Matches Mafia II: Definitive Edition on: 5 of 5 — Action, Adventure, Crime, Open World, Story Rich
Why players like it: Open World, Crime, Story Rich, Action, Singleplayer — the tags Steam players apply most
Price vs Mafia II: Definitive Edition: $39.99 — $10.00 pricier
Watch-outs: no widespread problems reported by players
Shared with Mafia II: Definitive Edition:CrimeStory RichSexual ContentThird-Person ShooterRemakeViolentThird PersonShooter
- 3
Mafia III: Definitive Edition
Why it matched: made by the same studio, Hangar 13; both open world, crime, story-rich and atmospheric; shares 11 player tags including Crime, Story Rich and Third Person; released around the same time (2020).
After Lincoln Clay's surrogate family, the black mob, is betrayed and killed by the Italian Mafia, Lincoln builds a new family and blazes a path of revenge through the Mafioso responsible.
Mafia III: Definitive Edition at a glance Released 2020 Studio Hangar 13 Player sentiment 57% positive of 64,063 Price $29.99 Verdict: GamingPickz Score 5.7/10 · Steam: (57% of 64,063)
Matches Mafia II: Definitive Edition on: 5 of 5 — Action, Adventure, Crime, Open World, Story Rich
Why players like it: Crime, Open World, Action, Story Rich, Singleplayer — the tags Steam players apply most
Price vs Mafia II: Definitive Edition: $29.99 — about the same price
Watch-outs: no widespread problems reported by players
Shared with Mafia II: Definitive Edition:CrimeStory RichThird PersonViolentShooterGreat SoundtrackThird-Person ShooterNudity
- 4
Mafia III
Why it matched: both open world, crime, story-rich and atmospheric; shares 11 player tags including Crime, Story Rich and Third Person; published by the same company; released around the same time (2016).
After Lincoln Clay's surrogate family, the black mob, is betrayed and killed by the Italian Mafia, Lincoln builds a new family and blazes a path of revenge through the Mafioso responsible.
Mafia III at a glance Released 2016 Studio Aspyr Player sentiment 57% positive of 64,036 Price $29.99 Verdict: GamingPickz Score 5.5/10 · Steam: (57% of 64,036)
Matches Mafia II: Definitive Edition on: 5 of 5 — Action, Adventure, Crime, Open World, Story Rich
Why players like it: Crime, Open World, Action, Story Rich, Singleplayer — the tags Steam players apply most
Price vs Mafia II: Definitive Edition: $29.99 — about the same price
Watch-outs: players report crashes and freezes, performance and stutter (details)
Shared with Mafia II: Definitive Edition:CrimeStory RichThird PersonViolentShooterGreat SoundtrackThird-Person ShooterNudity
- 5
Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas – The Definitive Edition
Why it matched: both open world, crime and story-rich; shares 11 player tags including Sexual Content, Crime and Third-Person Shooter; released around the same time (2023).
Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas: It’s the early ’90s. After a couple of cops frame him for homicide, Carl ‘CJ’ Johnson is forced on a journey that takes him across the entire state of San Andreas, to save his family and to take control of the streets.
Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas – The Definitive Edition at a glance Released 2023 Studio Rockstar Games Player sentiment 80% positive of 16,017 Price $59.99 Verdict: GamingPickz Score 7.0/10 · Steam: (80% of 16,017)
Matches Mafia II: Definitive Edition on: 5 of 5 — Action, Adventure, Crime, Open World, Story Rich
Why players like it: Sexual Content, Open World, Action, Crime, Third-Person Shooter — the tags Steam players apply most
Price vs Mafia II: Definitive Edition: $59.99 — $30.00 pricier
Watch-outs: no widespread problems reported by players
Shared with Mafia II: Definitive Edition:Sexual ContentCrimeThird-Person ShooterNudityViolentAction-AdventureThird PersonMature
- 6
Mafia II (Classic)
Why it matched: both open world, crime, story-rich and atmospheric; shares 8 player tags including Crime, Story Rich and Third Person; published by the same company.
Vito Scaletta has started to make a name for himself on the streets of Empire Bay as someone who can be trusted to get a job done. Together with his buddy Joe, he is working to prove himself to the Mafia, quickly escalating up the family ladder with crimes of larger reward, status and consequence… the life as a wise guy isn’t quite as...
Mafia II (Classic) at a glance Released 2011 Studio 2K Czech Player sentiment 94% positive of 58,640 Price $29.99 Verdict: GamingPickz Score 8.1/10 · Steam: (94% of 58,640)
Matches Mafia II: Definitive Edition on: 5 of 5 — Action, Adventure, Crime, Open World, Story Rich
Why players like it: Action, Open World, Crime, Story Rich, Atmospheric — the tags Steam players apply most
Price vs Mafia II: Definitive Edition: $29.99 — about the same price
Watch-outs: no widespread problems reported by players
Shared with Mafia II: Definitive Edition:CrimeStory RichThird PersonThird-Person ShooterShooterGreat SoundtrackClassicNudity
- 7
Red Dead Redemption
Why it matched: both open world, story-rich and atmospheric; shares 10 player tags including Story Rich, Action-Adventure and Third-Person Shooter.
Experience the story of former outlaw John Marston as he tracks down the last remaining members of the notorious Van der Linde Gang in the PC debut of the critically acclaimed predecessor to Red Dead Redemption 2.
Red Dead Redemption at a glance Released 2010 Studio Not recorded Player sentiment 92% positive of 21,331 Price $49.99 Verdict: GamingPickz Score 8.0/10 · Steam: (92% of 21,331)
Matches Mafia II: Definitive Edition on: 4 of 5 — Action, Adventure, Open World, Story Rich
Why players like it: Open World, Western, Story Rich, Singleplayer, Action — the tags Steam players apply most
Price vs Mafia II: Definitive Edition: $49.99 — $20.00 pricier
Watch-outs: players report crashes and freezes, launchers, accounts and anti-cheat, will not launch or install (details)
Shared with Mafia II: Definitive Edition:Story RichAction-AdventureThird-Person ShooterGreat SoundtrackShooterThird PersonSexual ContentClassic
- 8
Kane & Lynch 2: Dog Days
Why it matched: both open world, crime, story-rich and atmospheric; shares 9 player tags including Third-Person Shooter, Crime and Violent.
Pure adrenaline of non-stop action in Single Player, Online Co-op and Multiplayer. Double the pleasure and mayhem with new multiplayer DLCs! (click for details)
Kane & Lynch 2: Dog Days at a glance Released 2010 Studio IO Interactive Player sentiment 67% positive of 9,765 Price $9.99 Verdict: GamingPickz Score 6.2/10 · Steam: (67% of 9,765)
Matches Mafia II: Definitive Edition on: 5 of 5 — Action, Adventure, Crime, Open World, Story Rich
Why players like it: Action, Co-op, Third-Person Shooter, Crime, Violent — the tags Steam players apply most
Price vs Mafia II: Definitive Edition: $9.99 — $20.00 cheaper
Watch-outs: no widespread problems reported by players
Shared with Mafia II: Definitive Edition:Third-Person ShooterCrimeViolentShooterThird PersonMatureNudityStory Rich
- 9
Shadow of the Tomb Raider
Why it matched: both open world, crime, story-rich and atmospheric; shares 7 player tags including Third Person, Story Rich and Action-Adventure; released around the same time (2018).
As Lara Croft races to save the world from a Maya apocalypse, she must become the Tomb Raider she is destined to be.
Shadow of the Tomb Raider at a glance Released 2018 Studio Crystal Dynamics Player sentiment 85% positive of 87,978 Price $5.99 Verdict: GamingPickz Score 7.5/10 · Steam: (85% of 87,978)
Matches Mafia II: Definitive Edition on: 4 of 5 — Action, Adventure, Open World, Story Rich
Why players like it: Adventure, Action, Female Protagonist, Singleplayer, Open World — the tags Steam players apply most
Price vs Mafia II: Definitive Edition: $5.99 — $24.00 cheaper
Watch-outs: players report performance and stutter, crashes and freezes (details)
Shared with Mafia II: Definitive Edition:Third PersonStory RichAction-AdventureViolentShooterGoreGreat Soundtrack
- 10
Shadow of the Tomb Raider: Definitive Edition
Why it matched: both open world, crime, story-rich and atmospheric; shares 7 player tags including Third Person, Story Rich and Action-Adventure; released around the same time (2018).
As Lara Croft races to save the world from a Maya apocalypse, she must become the Tomb Raider she is destined to be.
Shadow of the Tomb Raider: Definitive Edition at a glance Released 2018 Studio Eidos-Montréal Player sentiment 85% positive of 87,994 Price $5.99 Verdict: GamingPickz Score 7.7/10 · Steam: (85% of 87,994)
Matches Mafia II: Definitive Edition on: 4 of 5 — Action, Adventure, Open World, Story Rich
Why players like it: Adventure, Action, Female Protagonist, Singleplayer, Open World — the tags Steam players apply most
Price vs Mafia II: Definitive Edition: $5.99 — $24.00 cheaper
Watch-outs: no widespread problems reported by players
Shared with Mafia II: Definitive Edition:Third PersonStory RichAction-AdventureViolentShooterGoreGreat Soundtrack
- 11
Mafia
Why it matched: both open world, crime, story-rich and atmospheric; shares 8 player tags including Story Rich, Crime and Classic.
It’s 1930. After an inadvertent brush with the mafia, cabdriver Tommy Angelo is reluctantly thrust into the world of organized crime. Initially, he is uneasy about falling in with the Salieri family, but soon the rewards become too big to ignore.
Mafia at a glance Released 2002 Studio Not recorded Player sentiment 88% positive of 16,301 Price $14.99 Verdict: GamingPickz Score 8.0/10 · Steam: (88% of 16,301)
Matches Mafia II: Definitive Edition on: 5 of 5 — Action, Adventure, Crime, Open World, Story Rich
Why players like it: Action, Story Rich, Crime, Open World, Classic — the tags Steam players apply most
Price vs Mafia II: Definitive Edition: $14.99 — $15.00 cheaper
Watch-outs: players report crashes and freezes (details)
Shared with Mafia II: Definitive Edition:Story RichCrimeClassicGreat SoundtrackThird PersonViolentThird-Person ShooterShooter
- 12
Hitman 2: Silent Assassin
Why it matched: both open world, crime, story-rich and atmospheric; shares 8 player tags including Third Person, Classic and Shooter.
Enter the realm of a retired assassin, forced back into action by treason. You may be a hired killer but you still have a sense of loyalty and justice. Visit the dark recesses of a world corrupted by crime, greed, degradation and dishonor. And a past that catches up with you.
Hitman 2: Silent Assassin at a glance Released 2002 Studio Not recorded Player sentiment 82% positive of 4,890 Price $8.99 Verdict: GamingPickz Score 7.3/10 · Steam: (82% of 4,890)
Matches Mafia II: Definitive Edition on: 4 of 5 — Action, Adventure, Crime, Story Rich
Why players like it: Stealth, Action, Third Person, Assassin, Classic — the tags Steam players apply most
Price vs Mafia II: Definitive Edition: $8.99 — $21.00 cheaper
Watch-outs: players report will not launch or install, performance and stutter (details)
Shared with Mafia II: Definitive Edition:Third PersonClassicShooterGreat SoundtrackGoreCrimeThird-Person ShooterStory Rich
- 13
Grand Theft Auto: Episodes from Liberty City
Why it matched: both open world, crime, story-rich and atmospheric; shares 8 player tags including Third Person, Crime and Shooter.
Grand Theft Auto: Episodes from Liberty City includes both The Lost and Damned and The Ballad of Gay Tony together and does not require a copy of the original Grand Theft Auto IV to play.
Grand Theft Auto: Episodes from Liberty City at a glance Released 2010 Studio Rockstar North / Toronto Player sentiment 74% positive of 10,072 Price Not listed Verdict: GamingPickz Score 6.4/10 · Steam: (74% of 10,072)
Matches Mafia II: Definitive Edition on: 5 of 5 — Action, Adventure, Crime, Open World, Story Rich
Why players like it: Open World, Action, Automobile Sim, Third Person, Multiplayer — the tags Steam players apply most
Watch-outs: no widespread problems reported by players
Shared with Mafia II: Definitive Edition:Third PersonCrimeShooterThird-Person ShooterMatureGreat SoundtrackNudityStory Rich
- 14
Yakuza 0
Why it matched: both open world, crime, story-rich and atmospheric; shares 7 player tags including Story Rich, Great Soundtrack and Crime; released around the same time (2018).
SEGA’s legendary Japanese series finally comes to PC. Fight like hell through Tokyo and Osaka as junior yakuza Kiryu and Majima. Take a front row seat to 1980s life in Japan in an experience unlike anything else in video gaming, with uncapped framerates and 4K resolutions. A legend is born.
Yakuza 0 at a glance Released 2018 Studio Ryu Ga Gotoku Studio Player sentiment 95% positive of 77,742 Price Not listed Verdict: GamingPickz Score 8.4/10 · Steam: (95% of 77,742)
Matches Mafia II: Definitive Edition on: 5 of 5 — Action, Adventure, Crime, Open World, Story Rich
Why players like it: Story Rich, Action, Beat 'em up, Great Soundtrack, Crime — the tags Steam players apply most
Watch-outs: no widespread problems reported by players
Shared with Mafia II: Definitive Edition:Story RichGreat SoundtrackCrimeViolentMatureSexual ContentThird Person
- 15
Yakuza Kiwami
Why it matched: both open world, crime, story-rich and atmospheric; shares 7 player tags including Story Rich, Crime and Great Soundtrack; released around the same time (2019).
SEGA’s critically-acclaimed entry that started a legend. Become Kazuma Kiryu, an up-and-coming yakuza who takes the fall for the murder of a crime boss, only to emerge from prison ten years later to a changed world. Remastered from the ground up, now in 4K and uncapped framerates on PC.
Yakuza Kiwami at a glance Released 2019 Studio Ryu Ga Gotoku Studio Player sentiment 93% positive of 23,315 Price Not listed Verdict: GamingPickz Score 7.9/10 · Steam: (93% of 23,315)
Matches Mafia II: Definitive Edition on: 5 of 5 — Action, Adventure, Crime, Open World, Story Rich
Why players like it: Action, Story Rich, Adventure, Beat 'em up, RPG — the tags Steam players apply most
Watch-outs: no widespread problems reported by players
Shared with Mafia II: Definitive Edition:Story RichCrimeGreat SoundtrackViolentThird PersonSexual ContentRemake
- 16
Max Payne 2: The Fall of Max Payne
Why it matched: both crime, story-rich and atmospheric; shares 9 player tags including Noir, Third-Person Shooter and Classic.
Max Payne 2: The Fall of Max Payne is a violent, film-noir love story. Dark, tragic and intense, the in-depth story is a thrill-ride of shocking twists and revelations. Love hurts.
Max Payne 2: The Fall of Max Payne at a glance Released 2003 Studio Not recorded Player sentiment 94% positive of 14,615 Price $2.49 Verdict: GamingPickz Score 8.1/10 · Steam: (94% of 14,615)
Matches Mafia II: Definitive Edition on: 4 of 5 — Action, Adventure, Crime, Story Rich
Why players like it: Action, Noir, Third-Person Shooter, Classic, Bullet Time — the tags Steam players apply most
Price vs Mafia II: Definitive Edition: $2.49 — $27.50 cheaper
Watch-outs: players report will not launch or install, crashes and freezes (details)
Shared with Mafia II: Definitive Edition:NoirThird-Person ShooterClassicStory RichShooterThird PersonGreat SoundtrackCrime
- 17
Sleeping Dogs
Why it matched: both open world, crime, story-rich and atmospheric; shares 7 player tags including Third Person, Crime and Story Rich.
As Wei Shen, an undercover cop trying to take down the Triads, you'll have to fight your way up the organization without blowing your cover.
Sleeping Dogs at a glance Released Not recorded Studio United Front Games Player sentiment 94% positive of 17,264 Price Not listed Verdict: GamingPickz Score 7.9/10 · Steam: (94% of 17,264)
Matches Mafia II: Definitive Edition on: 5 of 5 — Action, Adventure, Crime, Open World, Story Rich
Why players like it: Open World, Action, Martial Arts, Third Person, Crime — the tags Steam players apply most
Watch-outs: no widespread problems reported by players
Shared with Mafia II: Definitive Edition:Third PersonCrimeStory RichGreat SoundtrackViolentThird-Person ShooterShooter
- 18
Watch Dogs 2
Why it matched: both open world, crime, story-rich and atmospheric; shares 6 player tags including Third Person, Shooter and Crime; released around the same time (2016).
Welcome to San Francisco. Play as Marcus, a brilliant young hacker, and join the most notorious hacker group, DedSec. Your objective: execute the biggest hack of history.
Watch Dogs 2 at a glance Released 2016 Studio Ubisoft Romania Player sentiment 82% positive of 101,471 Price $49.99 Verdict: GamingPickz Score 7.3/10 · Steam: (82% of 101,471)
Matches Mafia II: Definitive Edition on: 5 of 5 — Action, Adventure, Crime, Open World, Story Rich
Why players like it: Open World, Hacking, Illuminati, Multiplayer, Parkour — the tags Steam players apply most
Price vs Mafia II: Definitive Edition: $49.99 — $20.00 pricier
Watch-outs: players report visual glitches, crashes and freezes, performance and stutter, launchers, accounts and anti-cheat (details)
Shared with Mafia II: Definitive Edition:Third PersonShooterCrimeThird-Person ShooterMatureStory Rich
- 19
Max Payne
Why it matched: both crime, story-rich and atmospheric; shares 9 player tags including Noir, Classic and Third-Person Shooter.
Max Payne is a man with nothing to lose in the violent, cold urban night. A fugitive undercover cop framed for murder, hunted by cops and the mob, Max is a man with his back against the wall, fighting a battle he cannot hope to win. Prepare for pain…
Max Payne at a glance Released 2001 Studio Not recorded Player sentiment 89% positive of 15,818 Price $3.49 Verdict: GamingPickz Score 8.0/10 · Steam: (89% of 15,818)
Matches Mafia II: Definitive Edition on: 4 of 5 — Action, Adventure, Crime, Story Rich
Why players like it: Action, Noir, Classic, Third-Person Shooter, Bullet Time — the tags Steam players apply most
Price vs Mafia II: Definitive Edition: $3.49 — $26.50 cheaper
Watch-outs: players report crashes and freezes, will not launch or install, audio and subtitles, performance and stutter (details)
Shared with Mafia II: Definitive Edition:NoirClassicThird-Person ShooterStory RichThird PersonShooterGreat SoundtrackCrime
- 20
L.A. Noire
Why it matched: both open world, crime, story-rich and atmospheric; shares 7 player tags including Crime, Noir and Story Rich.
In his fight to climb the ranks and do what's right, LAPD detective Cole Phelps must unravel the truth behind a string of arson attacks, conspiracies, and brutal murders, battling the L.A. underworld and even members of his own department.
L.A. Noire at a glance Released 2011 Studio Team Bondi Player sentiment 86% positive of 36,822 Price $19.99 Verdict: GamingPickz Score 7.7/10 · Steam: (86% of 36,822)
Matches Mafia II: Definitive Edition on: 5 of 5 — Action, Adventure, Crime, Open World, Story Rich
Why players like it: Detective, Crime, Open World, Noir, Adventure — the tags Steam players apply most
Price vs Mafia II: Definitive Edition: $19.99 — $10.00 cheaper
Watch-outs: no widespread problems reported by players
Shared with Mafia II: Definitive Edition:CrimeNoirStory RichThird PersonMatureNudityThird-Person Shooter
- 21
The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion
Why it matched: both open world, story-rich and atmospheric; shares 7 player tags including Third Person, Story Rich and Action-Adventure; published by the same company.
Explore Cyrodiil like never before with stunning new visuals and refined gameplay in The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion™ Remastered.
The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion at a glance Released 2006 Studio 4J Studios Player sentiment 75% positive of 70,052 Price $49.99 Verdict: GamingPickz Score 6.9/10 · Steam: (75% of 70,052)
Matches Mafia II: Definitive Edition on: 4 of 5 — Action, Adventure, Open World, Story Rich
Why players like it: RPG, Open World, Fantasy, Singleplayer, Adventure — the tags Steam players apply most
Price vs Mafia II: Definitive Edition: $49.99 — $20.00 pricier
Watch-outs: players report performance and stutter, crashes and freezes, will not launch or install (details)
Shared with Mafia II: Definitive Edition:Third PersonStory RichAction-AdventureGreat SoundtrackViolentSexual ContentGore
- 22
Red Dead Redemption 2
Why it matched: both open world, story-rich and atmospheric; shares 7 player tags including Story Rich, Shooter and Mature; released around the same time (2018).
Arthur Morgan and the Van der Linde Gang are outlaws on the run. With federal agents and bounty hunters massing on their heels, the gang must rob, steal, and fight their way across the rugged heartland in order to survive.
Red Dead Redemption 2 at a glance Released 2018 Studio Not recorded Player sentiment 92% positive of 911,659 Price $14.99 Verdict: GamingPickz Score 8.7/10 · Steam: (92% of 911,659)
Matches Mafia II: Definitive Edition on: 4 of 5 — Action, Adventure, Open World, Story Rich
Why players like it: Open World, Story Rich, Western, Adventure, Multiplayer — the tags Steam players apply most
Price vs Mafia II: Definitive Edition: $14.99 — $15.00 cheaper
Watch-outs: players report crashes and freezes (details)
Shared with Mafia II: Definitive Edition:Story RichShooterMatureThird-Person ShooterGreat SoundtrackThird PersonGore
- 23
Yakuza 3 Remastered
Why it matched: both open world, crime and story-rich; shares 7 player tags including Story Rich, Third Person and Crime; released around the same time (2021).
Kazuma Kiryu has earned his retirement on the sandy beaches of Okinawa. But when a deadly power struggle arrives on his doorstep, he’ll have to walk the streets of Kamurocho to escape his past for good. Complete The Dragon of Dojima’s journey.
Yakuza 3 Remastered at a glance Released 2021 Studio RGG Studio Player sentiment 81% positive of 10,239 Price Not listed Verdict: GamingPickz Score 6.9/10 · Steam: (81% of 10,239)
Matches Mafia II: Definitive Edition on: 5 of 5 — Action, Adventure, Crime, Open World, Story Rich
Why players like it: Action, Adventure, Beat 'em up, Open World, Story Rich — the tags Steam players apply most
Watch-outs: no widespread problems reported by players
Shared with Mafia II: Definitive Edition:Story RichThird PersonCrimeViolentSexual ContentGreat SoundtrackAction-Adventure
- 24
Max Payne 3
Why it matched: both open world, story-rich and atmospheric; shares 8 player tags including Third-Person Shooter, Story Rich and Shooter.
No longer a New York City cop, Max Payne moves to São Paulo to protect a wealthy family in an effort to finally escape his troubled past. This complete edition of Max Payne 3 includes the complete original game and all previously released downloadable content.
Max Payne 3 at a glance Released 2012 Studio Rockstar Vancouver Player sentiment 87% positive of 64,035 Price $5.99 Verdict: GamingPickz Score 7.9/10 · Steam: (87% of 64,035)
Matches Mafia II: Definitive Edition on: 4 of 5 — Action, Adventure, Open World, Story Rich
Why players like it: Action, Third-Person Shooter, Bullet Time, Story Rich, Multiplayer — the tags Steam players apply most
Price vs Mafia II: Definitive Edition: $5.99 — $24.00 cheaper
Watch-outs: players report crashes and freezes (details)
Shared with Mafia II: Definitive Edition:Third-Person ShooterStory RichShooterThird PersonNoirGreat SoundtrackViolentNudity
Common questions
What game is most like Mafia II: Definitive Edition?
Mafia II, on the evidence we have. It both open world, crime, story-rich and atmospheric. That is a statement about overlap, not a promise you will like it as much: two games can share every tag and still feel different to play.
How is "similar to Mafia II: Definitive Edition" decided?
By overlap on the tags Steam players applied to each game, the formal genres, the themes both sit in, and whether the same studio made them. Tags carry the most weight because players write them, so they describe how a game feels rather than how it was filed. Tags carried by more than a third of the catalogue are ignored: matching on "Singleplayer" is matching on nothing. Every entry below shows exactly what it matched on.
Are these ranked by quality?
No. They are ordered by how much they overlap with Mafia II: Definitive Edition. Where two games overlap equally, the better received one goes first, but that only moves a game a place or two. Each entry shows its own player sentiment so you can weigh that separately.
What else did the makers of Mafia II: Definitive Edition do?
Mafia: Definitive Edition, Mafia III: Definitive Edition are also from Hangar 13, and appear in the list below for that reason as well as on tag overlap.
Do you get paid for these recommendations?
No. The order is computed from tag and genre overlap and nothing else. No placement here can be bought, and a game appearing high on this page is a statement about resemblance rather than an endorsement.